
Well, since we’ve got the interview over with—and since there’s not much else I care to discuss at the moment—I guess I can go back to answering Griffin’s mail bag, eh? I don’t know… you got anything better?
Well, OK, I could respond to this Ken Fidlin piece in the Toronto Sun where Cito Gaston explains what he thinks the team needs next season—how cute!—but it would be quick and predictably pissy, so… pass.
Q: Read your piece on Johnny Mac - wonderful read! I hope Cito read it too and does give him the start in that last home game; the fans deserve that pleasure as much as McDonald himself. I have two related questions for you. Where do you see McDonald landing next year? Is there a team out there that appears to fit for him more than another? Secondly, while it seems obvious (and positive!) that the Jays will try to resign Marco Scutaro, who do see them turning to in the event that he signs elsewhere? The only name that comes to mind immediately is Orlando Cabrera, someone I know they expressed interest in last year. Thanks, as always!
Jon Empringham, Woodstock, Ont.
Well, obviously Johnny Mac will be starting for the foreseeable future, what with Marco’s lower body injury. Scutaro seems to think he can make it back to play this season, but… why? I’m sure he’ll be ready for the Venezuelan Winter Ball season, though, for all you LVBP poolies.
What happens in the off-season could go a number of ways. There is no ready replacement for Scutaro in the Jays system—thank you very much, JP Ricciardi—so they’ll have to look elsewhere for him if he doesn’t re-sign. O-Cab is clinging to Type A free agent status according to Eddie Bajek’s latest crack at the Elias Rankings over on MLBTR, and I imagine that, coupled with his .683 OPS, would be enough to scare teams off. I’ve said a number of times—even though I’m not sure I believe it myself—that I think teams are going to be scared off by the red flags on Scutaro—his age, asking price, the fact that he’s Type A and will require surrendering a high draft pick to the Jays, and the fact that he’s never had a season nearly as good as this one in his career—which may have him wind up back in the Jays’ lap at a reasonable price. The shortstop market is kind of shit though, which is why I’m not sure that will happen, but if it does, I hope they re-sign him.
There’s word of JJ Hardy possibly being made available for trade, and the Jays have some young starting pitching that should have no trouble dealing with the shitbag lineups in the NL, which the Brewers would probably covet, so maybe there’s something there, but honestly, until we know whether the Jays will have the money to aim high, or whether they’ll have to either get creative or take their usual trip to the scrap heap, it’s hard to say what’s going to happen.
As for Johnny Mac… speaking of shitbag lineups in the NL, he certainly seems like he might be a better fit in the AAAA League, where the lineups won’t make his bat look quite so glaringly awful, and where there are managers who might actually make an intelligent defensive substitution once in a while. I have no idea, specifically, who might want him, but with his defensive ability, he’s always going to have a job somewhere. (Well, not always, but you know what I mean…)
Q: Hi Richard Stoeten:
In your last mailbag, Sept 16, you said the Jays should field their best defensive team. Given the errors, missed cutoff men and missed defensive opportunities generally I could not agree with you more. In listing the lineup that would provide that defence you placed Lind at DH and Snider in left field. Shouldn't that be reversed? Snider is consistently missing cutoffs and sometimes seems shaky out there. (A ball went off his glove on what should have been a catch this past week.) Isn't Lind currently a better defensive option? This would also allow Snider to focus on how to deal with big league pitching. Keep up the great work!
Tim Rorke, Timmins, Ont.
Um… holy fuck no. Snider is not going to win any Gold Gloves, but I’ll take a couple missed cutoff men and the odd clanger off the glove over watching Adam Lind’s Adventures In Finding A Path To The Ball any day of the week and several more times on Sunday. Snider is at least passable and has the much better arm. Lind won’t absolutely kill you… kind of… but good fucking lord, ugh. No, it should definitely be Snider there.
As for my supposed claim that the Jays should field their best defensive team the rest of the year, one of us must have been high, because that’s fucking insanity. It’s vastly more important to take a look at the bats of guys like Randy Ruiz and Kyle Phillips than it is to worry about who is or isn’t a pylon in the field right now.
Q: Hi Richard Stoeten,
I have followed the Jays now pretty closely for several years and read your mailbag with much intrigue. To me the Jays are really not that far off being a contender. We have two great power hitters in Hill and Lind. We have an under-performing star who I believe will no doubt bounce back in Wells. The Jays have a core group of good players. Except for the important win-loss column we are not terribly behind in overall stats with our big spending friends south of the border.
This is a big if, but IF we are able to spend a little more (Paul Beeston suggested we could see a roster worth $120 million given the right business plan) could we not put together a winning team next year? If you had the additional 55-odd million available to spend for next year, what would you do to get us over this bump? Am I in lala land here in thinking this is even possible?
Bryan Freeman, Oakville
Bryan, first off, I certainly am not ready call Aaron Hill a “great power hitter” just yet. He’s had a great season, it’s true, and he’s a very good hitter, but I’d be surprised if he’s able to duplicate these kind of power numbers. And Wells could take to shooting heroin in the dugout next season and still probably not be as bad as he has been this year, but I wouldn’t count on much of a bounce back from him.
Still, you’re not crazy to think it’s possible the Jays could patch a contender together in the off-season. I just wouldn’t hold my breath. Personally, I think they’re going to throw the fans a bone by handing out a few short-term, low-risk high-reward contracts to veterans this winter and hope for the best on the field, while trying to get their fucking shit together internally for a run a couple years down the line. I think they’re going to be able to put together a team capable of hanging with the Red Sox and Yankees (and Rays) through the balance of the summer, but probably in the same way they’ve been doing for years, unless they manage a pickup or two that really outperforms his contract—like Bobby Abreu this year, or Frank Thomas when he signed with the A’s the year before some other team flushed a bunch of money down the toilet on him.
Of course, if they manage a coup—or a coup d’etat as Sportsnet’s Ryan Johnson might say (hahaha)—like a Jason Bay signing, then I suppose they’d really have something to legitimately believe in, but again… I wouldn’t hold my breath.
Q: Hi Richard Stoeten,
Question I've been wondering for quite some time now. In pucks, players get paid less in the minors and more in the majors (two way contracts and all that); on the same note, how much do minor league players get paid when they get called up? Pro-rated version of the league minimum? And the same thing with guys who are signed and sent down; do they get their regular major league stipend or the minor league stuff? I tried figuring it out but I couldn’t find it anywhere. Let me know!
Nicholas Hung, London
Pass. Check Griff’s mail bag for the answer to the one.
Q: Hi there.
Why isn’t Cito Gaston playing Randy Ruiz on a more constant basis? The season has been over for months now and this is a great time to see what he’s got. From what I've seen, this guy seems to hit a bomb every three or four games. Why isn’t he in the lineup everyday? Ruiz could be in the starting nine next year with the type of power he’s showing.
Dave Roberts, Brantford
Well, Dave, it beats the living fuck out of me. But… let’s not go nuts. Ruiz deserves a chance, absolutely. I think it’s asinine to not worry about pissing away a chance to get more data on what he can do at the major league level, instead figuring that it’s fine to take wait until next spring to take a look. It’s just, I suspect the Jays are hoping to have a more proven commodity in the DH spot next year, with Ruiz as a backup plan, regardless of what he does this month. If they go ahead and give Ruiz a full-time gig next year they might as well wave their white flag on April 1, because it will mean they spent fuck all over the winter, and are in the beginning stages of a full-on rebuild. So… ugh.
But I do have mixed feelings about this. I mean, what the fuck are these meaningless games for if not for taking a look at a guy like Ruiz who has absolutely nothing left to prove at any other level? It’s ridiculous that they’re not playing him, because you’d think there’d probably be some role for him here next year—limited as it may be—if you think he can handle MLB pitching. So, why not take a look? But that doesn’t mean I think that, even if they were playing him every day and he was absolutely killing it, they should hand him the DH job next year based on that.
Q: Hi Richard,
Let's say in a wildly altruistic move, Vernon Wells decides to option out of his contract so he can play for a team in the playoff hunt, or close to home or just wants to get rid of the criticism. Would the player's union allow him to do that? At the least, wouldn't they advise him not to opt out? I know their concern is for their players to make top dollar.
Kevin Layman, St. John's
I don’t know the ins-and-outs all that well, but I’d wager that while the PA would have a bit of a fucking hissy fit about it, I don’t think they could actually force him to do anything. Not that there’s a chance in hell he’ll do it anyway. And frankly, I disdain the whole idea some fans have that they might be able to make Vernon so intensely fucking miserable that he might choose to stop being a fucking lead weight around the franchise’s neck. It’s absolutely the wrong course of action to take, and I don’t just say that because I loathe the thought of anything that encourages fans who come down to Rogers Centre to act like bigger fucking assholes.
I mean, I guess I appreciate the attempt at logic which says that if VW could be made unhappy enough to actually fucking flush $60-million—but isn’t there a little more logic in taking a look at his home/road splits this year (.307/.340/.454/.794 on the road, and .214/.287/.347/.634 at home [Note: HOLY FUCK.]) and thinking… hey… maybe the fucking suffocating criticism raining ubiquitously down from the stands is—I don’t know—making him worse???
I mean, for fuck sakes people, if you had the same player at home that you’ve got on the road… that’s fucking fine. Not $20-million per year fine, but fine—as in not un-be-fucking-lievably shitbaggingly brutal.